What happens if indirect costs are less than the negotiated rate?
The largest portion of indirect costs is always given to the University for building maintenance and facilities budgets. Costs for upper campus administration and facilities use up the majority of the indirect costs that are charged. Schools are given the remainder to apportion between themselves and their departments.
When a grant is housed off-campus, the indirect costs are half of what they would normally be. This is partially because the grant does not pay for facilities costs and partially because the schools and departments involved have fewer costs. In the case of off-campus awards, upper campus takes a lower portion of the indirects.
Many foundations cap indirect costs at a rate far below the approved rate: normally at 15% or 10% and sometimes even at 0%. When indirect costs are lower than normal, the loss of revenue is taken at the school and department level, and both units are required to absorb these costs.
Some training grants are capped at 8% indirect costs. The reason for this is that the training grants are meant to be extensions of the regular curricula. Many of the extra costs incurred by this grant are costs that should be covered by state budgets and tuition costs. In this case, all the indirect costs are used to cover the extra upper-campus costs since they do not receive money from tuition revenues or the state for their extra work. Once again, the department receives no money from indirect costs from these grants.
What if I want to apply for a grant that has less than the negotiated rate?
If the funding agency does not provide an indirects policy statement on their website, the University’s Office of Sponsored Programs will require the Department Chair and Dean to approve a Request for Waiver of Indirects form. This confirms that the tangible loss of operations revenue is approved by both department and school.
Before applying for a grant with a low indirect cost rate, meet with your departmental administrator and chair. They will be able to determine if the department will support a grant that does not cover its own extra costs.
Just because the department will receive no indirect costs does not mean that the grant will not be approved. Some projects require little extra work for the department and waiving the indirect costs will have little effect. Some larger foundation grants have the ability to charge costs that are unallowable on federal grants and they can make up for the lost indirect costs. Still other grants will be costly, but will add prestige and provide new opportunities for the school. Each grant must be evaluated by itself.
Before you start planning a grant, you will have to determine:
- What infrastructure and administrative costs will the department have to cover? Can the department budget absorb these costs? Can these costs be charged to the grant? (This must be resolved with the departmental chair and administrator.)
- What costs will the rest of campus have to cover? How much per year will they lose? How many years? (This should be approved by OSP before the application is prepared.)
- What benefits will the project provide?
For further details and reference please see GIM 23, Attachment A – A Primer on Facilities and Administrative Costs.